‘Dangerous for Democracy’: Paramount Merger Opponents File Emergency Motion to Fight Settlement Deal
Por Jake Johnson — Common Dreams
Opponents of Paramount’s proposed acquisition of Warner Bros. Discovery filed an emergency motion in federal court on Thursday asking the judge overseeing the merger proceedings to grant them an opportunity to formally oppose a settlement deal that Paramount reached earlier this week with a coalition of state attorneys general, led by California’s Rob Bonta.
The merger opponents’ filing asks Judge Araceli Martínez-Olguín of the US District Court for the Northern District of California to give them “an opportunity to be heard” before she rules on the proposed consent decree between Paramount and the 12 state attorneys general—a deal that drew widespread outrage. The anti-merger coalition—which includes Free Press, the Committee for the First Amendment, the Future Film Coalition, and other groups—described the tentative deal as “dangerous for democracy.”
The coalition’s filing was submitted shortly before a court hearing that’s scheduled to begin at 2:00 pm ET. Martínez-Olguín set the hearing to “address certain outstanding questions regarding the factual and legal underpinnings of the parties’ proposed consent decree.”
Mara Verheyden-Hilliard, a constitutional rights litigator who serves on the steering panel for the Committee for the First Amendment, said in a statement that “we believe the consent decree fails to meaningfully address or mitigate the harms that will be caused by this monopoly merger to the entertainment industry, diverse storytelling, independent filmmaking, consumer interests, a free press, First Amendment rights, and fundamentally, democracy.”
“It does not serve to benefit anyone except the owner family of Paramount and those holding political power, who will use this corporate consolidation as a proxy force for First Amendment suppression of disfavored expression and viewpoints,” Verheyden-Hilliard added.
Paramount is headed by David Ellison, the son of billionaire Oracle co-founder Larry Ellison, one of the richest people in the world and a megadonor to President Donald Trump.
If Martínez-Olguín approves the proposed consent decree and the merger is finalized, Paramount would control both CBS and CNN, as well as other major media properties such as HBO.
As part of the consent decree, Paramount committed to “News Editorial Independence Boards” for CBS and CNN comprised of five “established journalists.” Critics, including the Freedom of the Press Foundation (FPF), have characterized the proposed editorial independence boards as “worthless” and a potential “First Amendment nightmare.”
“The solution for the Ellisons letting Donald Trump and [Federal Communications Commission Chair] Brendan Carr police journalism is not to let attorneys general and judges police journalism too,” said Seth Stern, chief of advocacy at FPF, part of the anti-merger coalition.
“It’s to keep the government out of the newsroom, period,” Stern added. “No one seriously believes the Ellisons (or their rumored new investor Elon Musk) will do that, with or without a self-appointed sham editorial board, which is why this merger cannot proceed.”
The League of United Latin American Citizens and a group of religious leaders filed a separate motion on Thursday asking Martínez-Olguín to “defer entry of the decree” to “ensure this court has sufficient opportunity to consider the important issues raised” in the case.
“The proposed consent decree raises grave doubts whether the parties’ settlement adequately addresses the harms alleged in the plaintiff states’ complaint,” the filing reads.
Fonte: Common Dreams
